“Wow!” One word sums up oracle Charlie Cook’s take on the midterm election’s repudiation of Donald Trump.
The founder of the Cook Political Report has never seen the likes in 44 years of analyzing elections. When a Black Democrat gets elected to the Senate from Mississippi, it is biblical in proportion.
Cook spoke for the Harkin Institute at Drake University on Wednesday. The crowd of about 500 cheered when he mentioned Josh Turek or Rob Sand. Long frustrated, these folks came to revel.
“It didn’t have to be this bad,” Cook said. “It was the friendliest map you could imagine.”
All of it rings familiar: the Iran war, sky-high diesel and fertilizer prices, no more Saturday night sirloins, young families without hope of owning their own home.
“The political pain seemed to target red rural America,” Cook said.
Don’t we know it. Democrat Josh Turek rode that wave of resentment to break out of a dead heat with Rep. Ashley Hinson, who was thought to be the Republican heir to Sen. Joni Ernst. The betting markets had her up until the final weekend.
They could have hung onto Texas and South Carolina were it not for Trump. Cook sensed a serious turn around August. He pays attention to where the money flows. Actually, the turn happened months before when White citizens were shot to death by ICE agents in the Twin Cities. We were made aware that these tyrants play for keeps. Voters already anxious about the economy were repulsed.
That was the triggering event. The Iran war sealed the deal. The tsunami had been building a long time.
For 50 years, we have been told to get big or get out. In two thirds of Iowa, they got out. The family farm is in the rear view mirror. Storm Lake hasn’t been a union town in generations.
There was hope for change in 2008, and then came the Tea Party revolt of 2010. Trump stormed into office through the power of rural resentment in 2016. You’re willing to put up with the sleaze and nonsense so long as you get yours. But the endless wars and the indifference to the plight of common folk made Trump the most unpopular president since Harry Truman 80 years ago.
This midterm was a convulsion. It can swing as hard the opposite direction in 2028 if the Democrats don’t deliver the goods: a fair shot at the American Dream. To own a home, to see that your kids can do better, to be secure in your dotage. We don’t trust that is true anymore.
Beef prices aren’t coming down in the next two years. Energy won’t be cheap so long as Iran plugs up the flow and war consumes the world. Interest rates will climb. Voters will remain edgy as they lose ground in an economy where you are an after-thought.
Iowa took a big turn but split power between the Democratic governor, Rob Sand, and a Republican legislature. Sand recruited Republicans into his inner-circle immediately. Iowa has done well under divided government. The Vision Iowa program, the most successful community revitalization program in our history, arose from a split legislature and Gov. Tom Vilsack, a centrist Democrat like Sand. Vision Iowa lifted up rural places like Storm Lake. So there is precedence for guarded optimism. Things did get better at the margins, but not at the core.
It’s been painful watching rural Iowa contract over my 46-year career. As Cook said, it didn’t have to be this bad.
We need health care for everyone. We need public schools with nutritious food. You can’t build a community by treating certain people as second-class. You need a roof over your head and to know your family will be okay. We don’t ask that much. But the system would serve us cake. If you’re in France, that’s when they roll out the guillotine.
In the early going Republicans have responded to the rump kicking with cockiness and zeal. They are not as awed by the results as Cook. They are confident that the Democrats will be limp and ineffective. Sand, for one, is trying to co-opt his adversaries by bringing them in and signaling no lasting harm to their franchise. It might work. Or it might result in same-old, same-old with a fresh face out front.
Same-old: higher water rates, higher sales taxes, wages that allow you to aspire to Busch Light, lawyers in our pockets, and Johnny has to move to Chicago for a job that will service his debt for a marketing degree from Iowa State. Don’t breathe or you might get cancer. If you are a woman, consider Minnesota.
Do you sense that changing?
If not, prepare for another earthquake that leads to a tsunami bigger even than this one. No telling what it leaves in its wake.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here